Elden Ring DLC Weapon Wishlist: From Soulsborne Classics to Armored Core Firepower

The world of Elden Ring, while a breathtakingly original tapestry of myth and ruin, pulses with the unmistakable ancestral heartbeat of the Soulsborne lineage. The Tarnished's journey through the Lands Between feels like walking through a dream woven from the same ethereal thread as Lordran, Drangleic, and Yharnam—a dream where god-slaying is a family tradition and bald men in caves are the universe's most consistent pranksters. As the community eagerly awaits the Shadow of the Erdtree expansion in 2026, speculation has erupted into a glorious, chaotic festival of nostalgia, with players debating which legendary artifacts from FromSoftware's storied past should make a triumphant, dimension-hopping return. This isn't just about power; it's about legacy, sentiment, and the sheer, unadulterated joy of introducing a gun to a sword fight.

The Fists of Legacy: Punching Above Their Weight

Some warriors crave not a sharper blade, but a harder fist. Leading this charge is a call for the Vanquisher's Seal from Dark Souls 2, a ring that transforms bare knuckles into instruments of divine demolition. The journey to obtain it was a gauntlet—joining the merciless Company of Champions and collecting 50 Awestones was a trial that separated the devoted from the defeated. But the reward? Boxing your way through the high fantasy epic of Elden Ring would be like a master sculptor deciding to create a masterpiece using only a sledgehammer—brutal, unorthodox, and magnificently satisfying. The visual of a Tarnished, clad in the regalia of a demigod, opting to pummel Malenia into submission with nothing but enhanced haymakers is a comedy of power that writes itself.

The Sticks of Yore: Whacking Gods with History

For others, the weapon of choice is something decidedly less subtle: a big, honking stick. The Dragon Tooth, the colossal dragon-bone great hammer wielded by the legendary knight Havel the Rock, is a perennial favorite. Swinging this monumentally clumsy weapon is an experience every Souls veteran cherishes—a delightful dance of staggering wind-ups and earth-shattering payoffs. Bringing it to the Lands Between would be like introducing a cathedral's bell tower as a melee weapon; its sheer, impractical mass is the entire point.

From the Gothic streets of Yharnam, the Threaded Cane emerges as a more elegant, yet equally deadly, suggestion. This trick weapon, a cane that unfurls into a serrated whip, represents the deadly sophistication of Bloodborne. Its return would be a masterclass in violent versatility, allowing the Tarnished to switch between dignified pokes and savage, wide-arcing lashes. It’s the gentleman's choice for systematic deicide.

The Game-Changers: Breaking the Balance (and the Game)

Then come the suggestions that aren't just about nostalgia—they're about rewriting the rules of engagement entirely. The Black Knight Halberd from the original Dark Souls sits atop this throne. Not the balanced versions from later games, but the gloriously broken iteration that could carry a player from the Undead Asylum to Gwyn with laughable ease. Acquiring this in the DLC would be akin to finding a functional starship engine in a medieval forge; it's a power spike so severe it would trivialize challenges and turn the Tarnished into an unstoppable force of nature, a walking easy mode toggle.

But why stop at medieval arms? The top-voted suggestion boldly leaps across genres: A six-way rocket launcher or a minigun from Armored Core. Imagine the scene: after a tense, orchestral build-up, a Crucible Knight charges, only for the Tarnished to unveil a weapon of pure, industrialized carnage. The ensuing barrage would make the flimsy pistols of Bloodborne look like children's toys. This suggestion is less about homage and more about glorious, anachronistic overkill—like solving a complex philosophical debate with a volcanic eruption.

The Sentimental Souvenirs: Homages and Heart

Not all desires are born from a lust for power. Some are pure love letters to the past. The Firelink Greatsword, the coiled blade born from the bonfires themselves, is a prime candidate. As one fan noted, it would serve as a beautiful, understated homage to the series' roots, its design inherently tied to the concept of sanctuary and renewal that defined the Souls experience. Its presence would be a warm, familiar ember in the strange new world.

Similarly, the Symbol of Avarice, the creepy Mimic helmet that drains health but boosts item discovery, holds a special place. While Elden Ring (so far) lacks the iconic chest monsters, the game reuses the classic chest model, making the helmet's inclusion a perfect, mischievous callback. If Shadow of the Erdtree finally introduces Mimics, this item would shift from a fun reference to a vital piece of gear, completing a circle fans have been waiting years to see closed.

The Final Verdict: A Tarnished's Arsenal of Dreams

The community's wishlist is a fascinating mirror held up to the Soulsborne legacy. It reveals:

Weapon Type	Example	Core Appeal
Unarmed Power	Vanquisher's Seal	Pure, skill-testing bravado
Colossal Classic	Dragon Tooth	Nostalgic, weighty satisfaction
Elegant Trickery	Threaded Cane	Stylish, versatile combat flow
Game-Breaker	Black Knight Halberd	The ultimate power fantasy
Anachronistic Mayhem	Armored Core Minigun	Genre-blending, explosive fun
Sentimental Homage	Firelink Greatsword	Emotional connection to series lore

Whether it's the tactical brutality of Havel's Tooth, the elegant fury of the Threaded Cane, or the reality-shattering firepower of an Armored Core mech weapon, each suggestion represents a different love for FromSoftware's worlds. As 2026 approaches and the Shadow of the Erdtree looms, one thing is certain: the Tarnished's potential arsenal has never been more exciting, or more hilariously unpredictable. The only question that remains is what glorious, broken, or heartfelt relic will finally make the jump. 🗡️🛡️🔥